THE VALUE PORTFOLIO ...
        ... a different investment choice for 401(k) plan participants 

The Portfolio Manager
The portfolio is managed by Morningstar Investment Services, a provider of rating services and analytical research to the financial services industry. Morningstar provides two managed portfolios, a growth portfolio, "the Hare", and a value portfolio, "the Tortoise." The value portfolio is modeled on the Tortoise. Here is how Morningstar describes this portfolio:

"The portfolio has two goals: to outperform the S&P500Index and to generate positive returns regardless of the broad market environment. Companies in this portfolio tend to be large, moderate to low risk, and slow growing. We aim for all the companies to have an economic moat."

The Investment Strategy
In order to achieve the fund's objectives, the fund will consistently follow the strategy described:

(1) Companies in the portfolio will have a lower P/E ratio than that of the overall market. Value issues are those that can be purchased at a lower price compared to their earnings than growth stocks. It is anticipated that the market will recognize these as undervalued issues, causing their share prices to rise.

(2) Companies in the portfolio will have a lower share price relative to their book value (tangible or "hard" assets) than that of the overall market. Value issues are those that can be purchased at a lower price compared to their book value than growth stocks. It is anticipated that the market will recognize these as undervalued issues, causing their share prices to rise

(3) Companies in the portfolio will usually have a wide economic moat. An economic moat is a competitive edge that keeps others from entering the firm's turf. It may be the capital required to enter that business, intellectual property, economies produced by size, etc.) Companies with an economic moat have less market competition and greater control over their pricing.

The current (October 30, 2009) portfolio:

Holdings Morningstar Ratings and Fundamentals
Stock Name

Fair Value

Current

Size Of

Dividend

Stewardship

Berkshire BRK.B

$4,600

$3,285

Wide

0

A

Kinder Morgan KMB

56

48

Wide

8.8

B

First American FAF

50

32

Narrow

2.7

B

Novartis NVS

73

50

Wide

3.5

B

Walgreen WAG

38

38

Narrow

1.4

B

Lowe's Co LOW

36

21

Wide

1.8

A

Johnson & Johnson

80

60

Wide

3.3

C

Wal-Mart Stores WMT

60

49

Wide

2.3

B

General Dynamics GD

65

65

Wide

2.4

A

Automatic Data ADP

41

39

Wide

3.4

B

JP Morgan Chase JPM

47

44

Narrow

0.5

A

Cintas CTAS

35

30

Wide

1.6

C

Sysco SYY

35

25

Wide

3.9

B

Exxon Mobil XOM

87

68

Wide

2.5

B

Coca Cola KO

55

54

Wide

3.1

B

TransCanada TRP

36

31

Narrow 4.9

A

PepsiCo PEP

68

61

Wide

3.0

B

Proctor & Gamble PG

77

57

Wide

3.1

B

American Express AXP

54

33

Wide

2.2

B

Home Depot HD

35

26

Wide

3.4

B

3M Company MMM

85

73

Wide

2.8

B

Diageo DEO

80

61

Wide

4.8
Pfizer PFE

26

16

Wide

3.9

C

Expenses
Because this is a Model portfolio, it carries none of the usual mutual fund sales commissions, selling concessions, administrative expenses and fund manager costs.

Through TD Ameritrade transaction costs are $9.95 regardless of the number of shares, and BenefitWorks charges .0004583 monthly, or 55 one hundredths of one percent of assets annually to unitize the portfolio and maintain the daily NAV (net annual value, or share price) calculation. The average "no-load" managed mutual fund charges 1.4% of assets. Mutual funds purchased through insurance companies or banks may have additional fees.

 


Click here for a printable PDF
version of this information